Carbon Steel Pan Vs Teflon Pan: Which Is Better?

Professional kitchens in United States have long been fans of Carbon Steel pan, while Teflon pan is indeed a popular option for home chefs across the globe, particularly in the United States. The combination of these two kinds of cookware is ideal for any home chef.

To begin, we firmly think that both pans belong in your kitchen. Don’t worry if you need assistance making this selection. In this article, we’ll explain the major points that can help in choosing a better option between carbon steel pans Vs Teflon:

Comparison Between Carbon Steel Pan Vs Teflon

Carbon Steel Pan Vs Teflon Pan


Carbon Steel Pan is a cross between stainless steel & cast iron cookware, consisting of 99 percent iron and 1 percent carbon. A ceramic and PTFE coating is applied to the pan’s surface to prevent food from sticking, and stainless steel is the most common material for non-stick cookware.

The finest nonstick cookware like Teflon has a five-ply construction with a PTFE coating for easy cleanup. PTFE coating gives a long-lasting nonstick surface which is safe to use in the kitchen, while the 5-Ply body helps maintain heat and responds to temperature fluctuations.

Cooking surface

In both Carbon Steel & Teflon pan, a coating is applied to the surface that improves cooking.

Every new pan has to be seasoned with Carbon Steel’s layer of seasoning. As the seasoning ages, it develops a slippery covering called patina, which protects the food from contamination. To prevent corrosion, the Pan has a layer of protection that prevents moisture from reaching the metal.

The nonstick coating is still intact when you take it out of the packaging. PTFE is the greatest non-stick coating. It is 70 times more durable than Ceramic Cookware, completely non-toxic, and the longest-lasting coating Non Stick will have to offer. Even if you don’t use any oil, you can cook with it.


Because Teflon pan requires more materials to create, it is more costly than Carbon Steel Cookware. Alloys or mixtures of metals are included in both carbon steel & nonstick cookware, although the nonstick coating adds an additional expense when making the pan.

For $69 for an eight-inch Frying Pan and $95 for a twelve-inch Pan, sellers offer Carbon Steel Frying Pans. The price of a good 8-inch Teflon pan starts at $89 and goes up to $119 for just a 12-inch pan.


These two pans are a breeze to clean and maintain. All of the Cookware should not be washed in the dishwasher. If you use harsh cleansers, they may harm their surfaces, and it’s also possible for them to be scratched or damaged by other objects. Both pans should be completely cooled before cleaning them, and as much food removed as possible.

Depending on the amount of gunk remaining in your pan, you’ll need to do one of three cleaning processes. If you can, use a paper towel to wipe the Pan clean. Sprinkle a spoonful of neutral oil & kosher salt over the food residue and scrape it away with an old paper towel until it is gone.

Getting water involved is a final option for Carbon Steel if everything else fails. Fill your pan to the brim with water. Bring water to the boil over medium heat, and then use a Wooden Spoon to scrape out any food pieces that have gotten lodged.

Once the water has been removed, thoroughly dry the area with a towel and a low heat burner before rubbing it with a thin coating of neutral oil.

Using the soft spot of a sponge and a non-abrasive cleanser is all you need to clean your Teflon pan in no time at all.


No matter how hard you beat it, carbon steel pan is almost unbreakable. If accidentally rust it by mistake, scratch it, or try to cook omelets, there’s nearly always a method to get it back to its original condition.

With little vinegar and water, you can remove rust from a pan, fill in a nick in the pan’s surface, and clean even the most stubborn problems.

A common misconception is that Teflon pan only has a short lifespan. Teflon pan may not be as long-lasting as Carbon Steel, but if you take appropriate care of it, you may expect it to endure for many years.

Hand washing is recommended, as is avoiding the use of metal tools while cooking with it. Also, keep in mind that it is only oven compatible up to 500 degrees Fahrenheit.

What all can be cooked?

High-temperature searing and charring of meats and vegetables are made easier with the use of carbon steel cookware. In addition to being safe for use up to 1200F on a gas cooktop and as effective over an open fire, this cookware is also induction-compatible.

Cooking delicate things like fish & eggs, in addition to vegetables in a skillet, is a snap with Teflon pan. If you want to cook meats like steak and salmon, the Carbon Steel is your best choice.


However, there are certain limitations on what can be cooked in both Carbon Steel & Teflon pan.

You could always re-season your Carbon Steel Pan if it becomes stripped of its seasoning by acidic foods such as citrus, vinegar, wine and tomatoes.

You can prepare anything in a Teflon pan as long as you remember to warm it with food and oil in it before using it. Teflon pan may be used at any temperature below 500 degrees Fahrenheit; nevertheless, this is the maximum temperature at which it should not be used.


Teflon pan and carbon steel cookware go together like peaches and nectarines. With their varied strengths, each deserve a place on the counter in your kitchen

Using Carbon Steel Cookware, you can sear steaks and char veggies at high temperatures.

Teflon pan is the ideal choice for delicate dishes like scrambling eggs or grilling fish. The greatest non-stick coating on the market is provided by the PTFE coating, which is exceptionally robust and long-lasting.

2 thoughts on “Carbon Steel Pan Vs Teflon Pan: Which Is Better?”

  1. I just love it when you stated that Teflon pans have non-stick surfaces, making them the perfect kitchen utensil. I wanna buy some new equipment for my cooking area this weekend. I’ll consider this option when I make a purchase later on.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top